Question

An old lady made a gift of her property to her daughter with a direction to pay a certain sum of money to the maternal uncle by way of annuity. On the same day, the daughter executed a writing in favour of the brother agreeing to pay annuity. The daughter did not, however, pay the annuity and the uncle sued to recover it. Decide, whether the conetntion of the uncle is valid or not?​

Answer 1

Answer:

the conetntion of the uncle was not valid because the girl was being paid by her grandmother but, why would she share her grandmother's property wih him.

So, the girl has done right by not sharing her property.