Question

Ansaric
EXAMPLE 30
LEGAL PRINCIPLE: The State is liable for the
nature, in the same manner and under the same
conditions as any other employer. The State is no
liable when the act is in exercise of sovereign por
or in performance of an Act of State.
FACTUAL SITUATION: An army truck was dan
by a military driver. 'A' and was proceeding on dus
carry the army men on duty at different military pes
The truck hit a civilian, 'B' and caused material
in
The fact showed that the injury was caused due to al
and negligent driving of A. The injured civilian brought
a suit in tort against the Union of India. The suit
(a) Will succeed on the principle of qui facit
alium facit per se.
(b) Will
succeed
the
master-servant
relationship between the Union of India and
the military driver.
(c) Will fail as Union of India did not ratify rash
and negligent driving.
(d) Will fail as the incident occurred in the
discharge of sovereign functions of the State. ​

Answer 1

Explanation:

Ansaric

EXAMPLE 30

LEGAL PRINCIPLE: The State is liable for the

nature, in the same manner and under the same

conditions as any other employer. The State is no

liable when the act is in exercise of sovereign por

or in performance of an Act of State.

FACTUAL SITUATION: An army truck was dan

by a military driver. 'A' and was proceeding on dus

carry the army men on duty at different military pes

The truck hit a civilian, 'B' and caused material

in

The fact showed that the injury was caused due to al

and negligent driving of A. The injured civilian brought

a suit in tort against the Union of India. The suit

(a) Will succeed on the principle of qui facit

alium facit per se.

(b) Will

succeed

the

master-servant

relationship between the Union of India and

the military driver.

(c) Will fail as Union of India did not ratify

Answer 2

Answer:

A

Explanation:

will succeed master servant