English, asked by FehlingSolution, 2 months ago

Book 5 (Order of the Phoenix) Harry is completely understandable and doesn’t deserve the hate he gets. Y’all are seriously mean and need to check yourselves. Harry just saw Cedric die a few weeks before, his parents are dead, he can’t see his friends/Sirius, he’s living in an abusive home, the ministry have turned their back on him & have branded him a liar, he has no contact with the outside world minus the newspaper and Hedwig and he most definitely has PTSD. Also, just straight up he’s a 15-year-old boy and while I have never been a teenage boy, I can’t imagine that would be easy, Chosen One or not. I just dont understand why people hate his behaviour in that part? That's completely obvious, atleast I would have reacted the same way.
What do you guys think? ​

Answers

Answered by anjali1982
2

Answer:

The ministry has a large impact on the wizarding community. Some people are really superstitious and also blindly trust whatever the ministry says. Others only want to make money and use it to their benefit. I think Harry was right in acting the way he did. Umbridge was cherry on top of Harry's stress. Some people fail to respond correctly and end up hurting someone else. Harry was completely correct and he was right to be frustrated. Thankfully, Ron and Hermione were their to support him. He was under a lot of pressure and it was understandable that he was jumping at the opportunity to save Sirius. After all, Sirius was the only family he had left. Everyone just loves to get to the party after it had ended, so the ministry and all of the wizarding population realised their mistake at last. Unfortunately, it was too late to save Sirius and Harry was alone again.

Answered by Anonymous
8

Heck yes

Ministry totally lost their all brain cells in the 5th part

I mean, what more horrible can you expect when they even sentenced Headmaster to Azkaban (no god please no)

As for harry, your points are totally understandable

He is just a boy (OP Molly) , He lost his childhood love he need, got tortured by his annoying aunt and uncle (don't forget Dudley)

Just a some weeks ago, he had a breakdown while watching Cedric die just because he was a spare

Even got a howler from ministry just because he protected his brother from dementors

Why don't people take that with real life

just imagine losing everything u loved

Got tortured or locked by muggles (Ooff!!)

They should relate by placing themselve in harry place

come on guys, he has seen so many worst things at such a small age, many teens at his age shout their lungs off if they saw a roach or lizard crawling XD

I would have reacted the same way if I was in his place (Extra → firstly I had pushed Umbridge out of astronomy tower, then danced on the funeral. If I had any way to change 5th part, I would have stopped harry (myself) from going into ministry office for saving Sirius T^T. And also, kicked that Umbridge bit*h for slapping harry/me.... How can she touch my precious face you old lady)

Stop it

get some help

1 hate for Umbridge = 1 prayer for Harry

#potterhead

Edit : Why are all your questions so relatable

I seriously like your style

@_@

Similar questions