critically examine the case in the light of recent development
Answers
Answer:
In a democracy, there is nothing more important than the credibility of the electoral process. Recently, many political parties in India have been seeking a return to the ballot paper. The issue pertains to the efficacy and credibility of EVMs in conducting free and fair elections.
EVMs have brought a structure to the electoral process that did not exist during the ballot paper days when the number of invalid votes would often be high and incidents of booth capturing were a common phenomenon. However, recently the transparency and efficacy of EVMs have been questioned. The Election Commission of India faces the following challenges in this regard:
To prove to the electorate and the parties that the EVMs are not manipulated and tempered.
The EVMs are selected by computers on the principle of randomization which does not allow a prior knowledge or planned setting for a particular EVM in a particular constituency or at a particular polling booth. But the challenge before the commission is to account for the authenticity of these processes.
It is also being opined that the present EVMs are not technologically advanced and secure.
Ensuring an independent and robust verification system in the whole exercise of manufacturing and placement of EVMs, and registeration and counting of votes.
Though EC has decided to use Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) machines in all future elections, it is yet to take a decision on tallying all votes cast through EVMs. So far, it has only ordered recounting of VVPAT slips on pilot basis.
In recently concluded by-elections (e.g. in Kairana Lok Sabha by-elections) there were reports of last minute glitches with EVM and VVPAT which raises doubt about their functioning.
Another challenge is to procure required VVPAT without delay for the Lok Sabha elections 2019.
Considering the complexity VVPAT is introducing in to electoral process there is need for competent polling officers.
VVPATs are very complicated and slight mishandling can result in failure. E.g. In Meghalaya Assembly by polls more than 33 per cent VVPATs failed as the paper used was not suitable for the humid weather there.