Discuss how Brahmanical religion was biased towards women? Mention at least five points.
Answers
Answer:
o6zuzrzuuztzp6rprusxs46qsw4up86xe 69396e,
Explanation:
This is a study of the Brahmanical discourse on women in ancient India between 500 b c e
and 300 CE. It specifically addresses the question of the representation of women in certain
Brahmanical texts which were composed, compiled and written down during this period.
The thesis attempts to move away from a previous focus on the ‘status of women’ in
ancient ‘Hindu’ India and from an uncritical acceptance of Brahmanical texts as reflective of
social reality. Instead, it argues that under certain historical circumstances Brahmanism
evolved a particular discourse on women. This discourse, subsequently expressed in its texts,
saw women in essentialist terms, as sexually insatiable and, therefore, sinful. At the same
time, however, Brahmanism recognized that women had a vital role to play in the
reproduction of its envisioned social order, particularly in the maintenance of caste and
lineage purity and the family (all three being important pillars of the Brahmanical social
order). Therefore, women had to be controlled. My reading of the Brahmanical texts suggests
that the method of control evolved by Brahmanism to deal with this apparent dilemma was
the classification of women according to their reproductive abilities, a classification which
served to distinguish the normative from the ‘deviant’ woman. In this scheme, the mother
was the procreatrix and as such was accorded the highest status. Woman as the mother thus
became the primary normative categoiy. Furthermore, with motherhood came qualitative
changes in a woman’s kin and sexual status. Woman as wife or daughter formed the
secondary normative category. She enjoyed the status of a potential procreatrix, being yet to
fulfil her primaiy biological function. As a wife and daughter, therefore, a woman held an
ambiguous kin position. She was regarded as sexually dangerous, which led to an emphasis
on the wife’s chastity and the daughter’s virginity. This thesis argues that since, according to
Brahmanism, a woman was defined by her reproductive abilities, one who was not (or could
not be) a mother was by definition ‘deviant’. This category included the widow, the woman
ascetic and the vesya, women whose potential for procreation was not recognized socially.
It has often been argued that Brahmanical texts objectify women and that a study of such
texts perpetuates both the objectification of women and their portrayal as the ‘other’.
Therefore, after discussing the Brahmanical discourse on women, the thesis addresses the
question of the agency of women in ancient India. While not totally agreeing with the current
ethnographic studies on the ‘subversive’ activities of women within the patriarchal order, in
its concluding section, this thesis examines questions relating to women’s complicity with
and resistance against Brahmanical norms and categorizations in ancient India.