do you think that it is an auto nationalism poem or would you say that it is an anti war poem give reason for your it is class 9 next please give long answer poem name is no men are foreign
Answers
Answer:
The poem ‘ No Men Are Foreign’ by James Kirkup does not encourage anti-nationalist sentiments. Instead, it is an anti-war poem.
The poet focusses on the concept of universal brotherhood since he firmly believes he that all men ,including soldiers are the same everywhere.
Explanation:
The strongest evidence of the poem being anti-war and not anti-nationalist is the fact that no where in the poem does the poet refer to any one nation. In fact, his words apply to everyone irrespective of their nationality. This is evident from the title of the poem itself, "No men are foreign" . He is neither favouring any nation, nor denouncing his own country.
When the poet says “we who take arms against each other” he includes anyone and everyone who is involved in war. He does not specifically mention any particular nation. Instead he talks of defiling the entire earth. Thus, his address is to all the citizens of the world. Therefore, if he is asking his own countrymen to shun war, he is saying the same thing to people of other nationalities as well. The poet’s agenda is world peace.
Additionally, the poet is not against settling national issues. What he is against is using war as a means to resolve problems. He strongly feels that any issue can be resolved by love. He feels that war only causes destruction. It reduces life to “hells of fire and dust” and ruins the purity of air that is “everywhere our own”. Here too, the focus is how we live on a common earth and breathe in air that is common to everyone.
Repeatedly, the poet tries to bring out the commonness of the human race with the usage of the word “our”. The poet lays emphasis on the equality of all humans and is concerned by global issues, for war affects all the nations involved. Even if a nation wins, it suffers irreparable losses. The poem thus is far from being an anti-nationalist poem. It is in fact an anti-war poem.
Answer:
The literary work 'No Men are Foreign' by James Kirkup doesn't encourage anti-nationalist sentiments. Instead, it associates anti-war literary work.
Explanation:
The most reliable proof of the literary work being anti-war and not anti-nationalist is that the indisputable fact that wherever within the literary work the writer doesn't want to refer any nation. His words apply to everybody no matter of their status. This is often evident from the title of the literary work itself, "No men are foreign". He is neither affirmative among any nation, nor denouncing his own country.