India is federal in form but unitary in spirit.Discuss?
Answers
Answer:
Federalism is considered to be one of the most important aspects of modern constitutionalism. The Constitution of the United States of America is the first federal constitution in the world.
Federalism is considered to be one of the most important aspects of modern constitutionalism. The Constitution of the United States of America is the first federal constitution in the world. As it is democratic in nature and more suitable to a vast country like India, the framers of the Constitution accepted the federal form of Government.
Although the word “Federation” has not been used in our Constitution, Article I of the Constitution declares India as “Union of States”. The structure of the Indian polity is made federal and there is a dual polity and constitutional division of powers. An independent Judiciary is provided to interpret the Constitution and safeguard the rights of both the Centre and the States.
Thus there are all federal features in our Constitution; but at the same time the unitary spirit of the Constitution is not ruled out. The Union is more powerful than the Units. There is provision of emergency in which the State Governments can be suspended and put under the Central administration.
The appointment of Governors, the provisions of All India Services, integrated Judiciary, Single Citizenship, etc., are some of the features in our Constitution which promote unitarianism. This has led critics to say that the Constitution is largely unitary or “Quasi-Federal” one.
Another critic has said that the Constitution of India is “federal in structure and unitary in spirit”. It seems there is a happy blend between unitarianism and federalism in our Constitution. The framers of the Constitution were not motivated to produce a purely federal or purely unitary Constitution.
Federalism is considered to be one of the most important aspects of modern constitutionalism. The Constitution of the United States of America is the first federal constitution in the world.
Federalism is considered to be one of the most important aspects of modern constitutionalism. The Constitution of the United States of America is the first federal constitution in the world. As it is democratic in nature and more suitable to a vast country like India, the framers of the Constitution accepted the federal form of Government.
ADVERTISEMENTS:
Although the word “Federation” has not been used in our Constitution, Article I of the Constitution declares India as “Union of States”. The structure of the Indian polity is made federal and there is a dual polity and constitutional division of powers. An independent Judiciary is provided to interpret the Constitution and safeguard the rights of both the Centre and the States.
Thus there are all federal features in our Constitution; but at the same time the unitary spirit of the Constitution is not ruled out. The Union is more powerful than the Units. There is provision of emergency in which the State Governments can be suspended and put under the Central administration.
The appointment of Governors, the provisions of All India Services, integrated Judiciary, Single Citizenship, etc., are some of the features in our Constitution which promote unitarianism. This has led critics to say that the Constitution is largely unitary or “Quasi-Federal” one.
Another critic has said that the Constitution of India is “federal in structure and unitary in spirit”. It seems there is a happy blend between unitarianism and federalism in our Constitution. The framers of the Constitution were not motivated to produce a purely federal or purely unitary Constitution.
Please mark it as the BRAINLIEST answer.