English, asked by tanikaray, 1 year ago

Is it
My grandmother 'read' the newspaper last night
or
My grandmother was reading the newspaper last night?
Explain
URGENT!


tanikaray: I need the explaination of difference between simple past and past continous tense specially in this sentence 
devavikaas: dude both are correct but you use 'read the newspaper' when she completed reading and 'reading the newspaper' when you refer the time she hasn't completed reading
RikTheBrainyGuy: Both of them are correct. But using the sentence "My grandmother was reading the newspaper last night" would be more appropriate. 
saige: Ten people were sitting around the table. It was raining outside. Suddenly, the door opened and a woman entered the room. She was wearing a black dress. Everyone stared at, her but she didn't say anything. She slowly went to the table and put an envelope on it. They were just staring at her as she left the room.
Note the difference between these two sentences from the story:

Everyone stared at her.
They were just staring at her.
The past simple in the first sentence expresses a momentary, comp
RikTheBrainyGuy: U r right !
saige: thankssssssss
tanikaray: Thank you all so much !! Helped a lot for my exams !!1

Answers

Answered by Tanvi24
1
The correct one is My Grandmother was reading the newspaper last night.

tanikaray: Please explain !
devavikaas: ask me ill say
Answered by PinkyTune
4
Well, it's both (if it's not shocking)!

These two sentences make use of two types of past tenses.
One - past perfect tense.
Another - past continuous tense.

Whatever. But, both the sentences convey the same meaning, with a slight difference. Anyways, both sentences are grammatically correct. The sentence-structure and all.

There isn't any option like this one is correct and the other is not.

It's just that both the sentences in past tense convey a slightly different meaning. 
Each are two different CORRECT sentences which convey a differnt meaning.

I hope I was able to get to the point.

Now,  I will provide the explanation. What do the two sentences each mean?

PAST TENSE - It means something happenned in the past. By 'something', I refer to any event, action, or stuff like this. 'Something' has been completed in the past. It has completed taking place, already.

So, the first sentence 
Similar questions