Question

out of ch3ch2ch2+ and ch3ch2+ which is more stable carbocation
both are primary but
the former one has a bulkier alkyl group and hence more inductive effect
and the latter one has more no of alpha hydrogen and hence more no of hyperconjugative structures..
both the reasons are clashing......!!!!!
we expect the first one out of intuition but how can we forget the fact that hyperconjugaion is more dominant tha inductive effect?
plz ans asap!!!!!!!

Answer 1

Answer:

ch3ch2+ is more stable because we have go with hyperconjugation method becaus hyperconjugation is more stable than inductive effect

Answer 2

Answer:

CH3CH2CH2+ > CH3CH2+

Explanation:

Stability of carbocation is primarily related to the dispersal of the charge carried by the positively charged carbon. The dispersal of charge may be due to inductive effect, hyperconjugative effect or resonance effect. The relative stabilities of different kinds of carbocation can be measured in terms of heterolytic bond dissociation energies leading to the formation of the carbocation (A - X --------> A^+ + X^- ).