Question

was corporal turnbull correct in his discision of punishing private quelch

Answer 1

In my opinion the punishment was correct. Private Quelch had the bad habit of showing off his knowledge. He might be doing it intentionally but it hurt the others.

Answer 2

Yes Corporal Turnbull was right in punishing private quelch as he was tattered and ill mannered and he think that he know too much than the corporal Turnbull and from the others that s why corporal Turnbull was right in punishing private quelch