Question

Was Corporal Turnbull’s decision to assign cookhouse duties to Private Quelch a form of revenge or a just action ? Discuss the values Corporal Turnbull should have possessed in his treatment of Professor.

Answer 1

he should tell him properly
he should nt give like this punishment quelch is the student of him
he should nt have done that

Answer 2

Corporal Turnbull was a very decorated officer, and a war veteran. On one occasion during a class session of his, wherein he is into explaining about the properties of a grenade, Private Quelch questions his knowledge and is hence dared by Corporal Turnbull to continue the class. Indeed Quelch gives a befitting lecture, but it becomes very rude to cross one's senior, especially in Army, so to teach Private Quelch a lesson, Corporal Turnbull assigns him the duties in the cookhouse.
Yes, Corporal Turnbull could have been a little less vindictive towards him, and could have treated him sympathetically.