why did John ma
cpherson called James immediately ? of chapter the comet 1
its urgent
Answers
Macpherson published Critical Dissertations on the Origin, Antiquities, Language, Government, Manners, Religion of the Ancient Caledonians, their Posterity, the Picts, and the British and Irish Scots, London, 1768. This work on the Ossian controversy upheld the authenticity of the poems attributed to Ossian.[2] Though not closely related, James Macpherson, author of "Ossian", and John Macpherson knew each other well. They are thought to be complicit in the forged works.[3] The "Ancient Caledonians" of John Macpherson were from Gaul, ancestors of the Picts, Scots and Irish, a theory also adopted by James Macpherson.[4]
Critical Dissertations also attacked contemporary historians of Scotland, particularly William Robertson.[5] Macpherson claimed to have seen a reading of "Ossianic" verse, by a Gaelic bard; the poet in question has been identified, tentatively, as Dòmhnall MacMhuirich (fl. 1707–1740s), last representative of the MacMhuirich bardic family.[6][7]
Macpherson paraphrased the Song of Moses in Latin verse, published in The Scots Magazine. In the debate on second sight, with a cousin, Martin Macpherson of Golspie, he attacked "Theophilus Isolanus", pseudonymous author of a treatise on the topic, real name Donald Macleod.[1][8]