"animals should not be used for drug development or medical research "
express your views either for or against this statement .
Answers
Answer:
The man has from times immemorial exploited animals to serve his ends. They have been used for making his life comfortable by catering to his various needs. It is therefore against the basic tenets of morality to perpetuate pain and suffering on these poor creatures such as pigs, dogs, frogs, etc. on the pretext of facilitating medical research. This is for we have no right to destroy what we cannot create. The life of an animal is also precious and invaluable like we have for us. Destroying them in this manner is but trampling on their basic right to live.
Often people advocate the use of animals for medical research on the grounds of expedience for the larger benefit to mankind. Can such an absurd logic justify the daily extermination of millions of frogs, birds, etc. by school and college students to make them aware of the basic metabolic system? We all know that only a minuscule number of students actually pursue a career in medicine or pharmacology. The majority migrate to other field like commerce and arts. What a colossal waste of precious animal lives sacrificed at the altar of the above premise with no benefits accuring to mankind.
Such senseless killing of animals must make us hang our heads in shame. It shows our complete insensitivity towards them. At the same time killing them in such a wanton manner makes us cruel and uncaring for life even towards our own fellow human beings. This callous attitude to life is reflected in the growing incidence of violence in the society especially among the youth.
FOR
Since the beginning of time, man has used animals for his own purposes. Providing for all of his necessities has made his life pleasant. Therefore, it is wrong to continue to cause pain and suffering to these helpless animals, such as pigs, dogs, frogs and others, under the guise of advancing medical research. This is because we don't have the right to destroy things that we can't make. Like our own lives, an animal's life is priceless and invaluable. We are only violating their fundamental right to life by destroying them in this way.
It is wrong to use animals in drug testing or medical research for moral, ethical, and societal reasons. What man can't make, he has no right to destroy. Violence is becoming more and more prevalent in society as a result of a callous attitude toward life. The ecological balance of nature is in danger due to the extinction of several animal species.
(i) It is inhumane to experiment on animals. (ii) No right to destroy life. We cannot give life, so we should not take it. (iii) Animals are made prisoners, and tortured in the name of scientific progress. (iv) Do we know how many hundreds are killed in the name of the advancement of science?
(v) It leads to poachers killing precious wildlife for profit. The biggest examples are tigers in India. Their bones are used for medicinal purposes in China, and hundreds of tigers have been killed in India. They are almost becoming extinct.Animals shouldn’t be used in scientific research or medication development.
Our moral and ethical development is reflected in how we treat our animal resources. This is because, just like people, animals have fundamental rights, and we must treat them with the same compassion and kindness. This is true because animals, like people, can suffer and feel pain. They share the same degree of creation with the man that God does. Therefore, using them for trials, medication development, or medical research is entirely immoral.
AGAINST
The statement that "Animals should not be used in drug development or medical research" is one with which I completely disagree. Ending animal use in research would make it more challenging to comprehend health and illness, hindering the creation of important new medicines. Although these studies occasionally lower the quality of life for the animals, strict restrictions are in place to guarantee that they are carried out in a sensible way.
The health of the human race has significantly improved because of animal studies in medicine. It would be impossible to evaluate the side effects of vaccinations and medications without using animals. And animal experimentation was used in the development of several modern vaccines.
Direct testing on people would be very dangerous and nearly impossible. Animal testing is a current issue. Every human has a right to live. The main reason for this research is to serve life. It is worthwhile if a few animals are sacrificed to eliminate human suffering. Think of dreaded diseases like T.B., Cancer and AIDS. How can mankind be saved if scientists do not experiment? Please think of the lives saved by new drugs, new hope given to the sick and new life for their near and dear ones. It is neither unethical nor immoral to experiment because these experiments are made to serve humanity, save thousands of lives, and save people from pain and misery. The worst thing that can happen to anyone is seeing close family members endure unimaginable suffering. Nothing is wrong with conducting scientific research at the cost of a few animals. We must fight human greed, which promotes crime and the unnecessary killing of animals. Every citizen has to be vigilant.