Compare and contrast the quadruples triples and indirect triples
Answers
Answered by
8
1. Quadruple Representation :
Using quadruple representation, the three-address statement x = y op z is represented by placing op in the operator field, y in the operand1 field, z in the operand2 field, and x in the result field.
The statement x = op y , where op is a unary operator, is represented by placing op in the operator field, y in the operand1 field, and x in the result field; the operand2 field is not used.
A statement like param t 1 is represented by placing param in the operator field and t 1 in the operand1 field; neither operand2 nor the result field are used.
Unconditional and conditional jump statements are represented by placing the target labels in the result field.
For example, a quadruple representation of the three-address code for the statement x = (a + b) * - c/d is shown in Table 6.1. The numbers in parentheses represent the pointers to the triple structure.

2. Triple Representation
The contents of the operand1, operand2, and result fields are therefore normally the pointers to the symbol records for the names represented by these fields.
Hence, it becomes necessary to enter temporary names into the symbol table as they are created.
This can be avoided by using the position of the statement to refer to a temporary value.
If this is done, then a record structure with three fields is enough to represent the three-address statements:
The first holds the operator value, and the next two holding values for the operand1 and operand2, respectively. Such a representation is called a "triple representation".
The contents of the operand1 and operand2 fields are either pointers to the symbol table records, or they are pointers to records (for temporary names) within the triple representation itself.
For example, a triple representation of the three-address code for the statement x = (a + b)* ˆ’ c/d.

Indirect Triple Representation
Another representation uses an additional array to list the pointers to the triples in the desired order.
This is called an indirect triple representation. For example, a triple representation of the three-address code for the statement x = ( a + b )* ˆ’ c/d

Comparison
By using quadruples, we can move a statement that computes A without requiring any changes in the statements using A, because the result field is explicit.
However, in a triple representation, if we want to move a statement that defines a temporary value, then we must change all of the pointers in the operand1 and operand2 fields of the records in which this temporary value is used.
Thus, quadruple representation is easier to work with when using an optimizing compiler, which entails a lot of code movement.
Indirect triple representation presents no such problems, because a separate list of pointers to the triple structure is maintained.
When statements are moved, this list is reordered, and no change in the triple structure is necessary; hence, the utility of indirect triples is almost the same as that of quadruples.
Using quadruple representation, the three-address statement x = y op z is represented by placing op in the operator field, y in the operand1 field, z in the operand2 field, and x in the result field.
The statement x = op y , where op is a unary operator, is represented by placing op in the operator field, y in the operand1 field, and x in the result field; the operand2 field is not used.
A statement like param t 1 is represented by placing param in the operator field and t 1 in the operand1 field; neither operand2 nor the result field are used.
Unconditional and conditional jump statements are represented by placing the target labels in the result field.
For example, a quadruple representation of the three-address code for the statement x = (a + b) * - c/d is shown in Table 6.1. The numbers in parentheses represent the pointers to the triple structure.

2. Triple Representation
The contents of the operand1, operand2, and result fields are therefore normally the pointers to the symbol records for the names represented by these fields.
Hence, it becomes necessary to enter temporary names into the symbol table as they are created.
This can be avoided by using the position of the statement to refer to a temporary value.
If this is done, then a record structure with three fields is enough to represent the three-address statements:
The first holds the operator value, and the next two holding values for the operand1 and operand2, respectively. Such a representation is called a "triple representation".
The contents of the operand1 and operand2 fields are either pointers to the symbol table records, or they are pointers to records (for temporary names) within the triple representation itself.
For example, a triple representation of the three-address code for the statement x = (a + b)* ˆ’ c/d.

Indirect Triple Representation
Another representation uses an additional array to list the pointers to the triples in the desired order.
This is called an indirect triple representation. For example, a triple representation of the three-address code for the statement x = ( a + b )* ˆ’ c/d

Comparison
By using quadruples, we can move a statement that computes A without requiring any changes in the statements using A, because the result field is explicit.
However, in a triple representation, if we want to move a statement that defines a temporary value, then we must change all of the pointers in the operand1 and operand2 fields of the records in which this temporary value is used.
Thus, quadruple representation is easier to work with when using an optimizing compiler, which entails a lot of code movement.
Indirect triple representation presents no such problems, because a separate list of pointers to the triple structure is maintained.
When statements are moved, this list is reordered, and no change in the triple structure is necessary; hence, the utility of indirect triples is almost the same as that of quadruples.
Similar questions