Question

The soccer balls are ______ the garage.
in
from
with
at
into

Answer 1

in the garage is the correct answer

Answer 2

in the garage is correct...

This depends on context. 
A) would be used if "the garage" was the name of a shop 
B) would be used if your balls were being repaired at a football repair shop called "the garage" 
C) would be used in the same context as A and B 
D) is not good grammar no matter what 
E) is probably the one you want, as you are telling someone your balls are in the garage.